Skip to main content

The Metaverse Primer by Jefferies Part 3: Crime and Punishment



Earlier Parts of this series 

Part 1, Why Now?

 https://hadrianarcho.blogspot.com/2022/02/the-metaverse-primer-by-jefferies-part.html

Part 2, A Peculiar Economy

 https://hadrianarcho.blogspot.com/2022/02/the-metaverse-primer-by-jefferies-part_15.html

Introduction

At the beginning of this discussion regarding the Metaverse, I had already begun to think about the effects that a fully developed metaverse would have on crime, punishment, and censorship. Because of my rather sluggish writing process, I was not able to complete this part of the discussion before a very important news article arrived onto the landscape this year. You may or may not have heard of this piece of news, but some time ago, a lady had reported that she has been “raped” in the metaverse [1]. In the story, a woman from the UK, Nina Jane Patel, claimed that within a minute of joining the metaverse platform, Horizon Venues, a group of 3-4 avatars had sexually assaulted her [1] [2]. In more explicit detail from her personal blog on Medium, Nina expunges more details about what exactly the users had done to her [3]:

“I was verbally and sexually harassed — 3–4 male avatars, with male voices, essentially, but virtually gang raped my avatar and took photos — as I tried to get away they yelled — “don’t pretend you didn’t love it” and “go rub yourself off to the photo”.

On first glance, it’s obvious that Ms. Patel clearly has not been on the internet for a very long time, nor has she ever spent time in the grittier portions of the internet like the comments sections on youtube videos, Pre-Reddit forum sites, or even Xbox/Playstation/PC shooting game lobbies. If she had, there is little doubt that what she experienced would be a mild at best, and something worth a cry at night and not much else. You want an example of what I mean, the video below is a representation of what us longtime internet users are used to:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pu6HDd7gDr8

Aside from Ms. Patel’s sensitivities, what she does bring up in her case is interesting in the perspective of what the Metaverse means for crime and punishment.

Real and Digital Selves

In her blog, Ms. Patel brings up the question about the blurring of virtual and digital life. She brings up the notions that people can’t often distinguish between real and virtual experience and how this is exploited by metaverse platforms in order to the generate a lifelike feel to the metaverse. In her experience, Ms. Patel claims that she had a physiological response that had happened as it was real [3]. She’s correct in that people have a hard time distinguishing between real and virtual versions of themselves. It’s been repeated in a few studies concerning both the digital self and the nature of parasocial relationships on various tech platforms [4]. In other research, it’s been shown that people like to internalize the traits of their avatars, even if it’s not the reflections of themselves in the real world [5]. So, if people have a problem differentiating between their virtual self and their digital self, than how is crime handled when it comes to these online events like a virtual gangbang? Traditionally, when it comes to online crime in the United States, there seems to be a differentiator in the application of the law depending on whether the crime at hand is “hard” or “soft.” For example, it’s rather rare that someone on the internet gets arrested for illegal distribution of content online. Millions of people in the US use torrenting software or use streaming site to watch content and the last big case of online piracy I can think of that went to court was the case of Aaron Schwartz since he was downloading large amounts of research papers onto his own drives to make them free [6]. On the other hand, more people get arrested online for hard crimes done online like drug trafficking, like in the case against the silk road, an underground internet operation that was used to sell drugs online [7]. In the case of sexual assault, this is currently classified as a soft crime since no hard law was applied to the case and no follow ups or arrests were made to the people that sexually assault Ms. Patel.

Jurisdiction

One of the things that interests me a lot is the idea of jurisdiction. As we’ve touched on above, there’s going to be a degradation between real and virtual selves in a metaverse world. Since the line is now blurred, who does get jurisdiction in the case of Ms. Patel? Is it the government of the country that she is in? In some countries, such as the UK or Australia, the authorities already take an extensive role in the policing of behavior on the internet [8] [9]. On the other hand, the US has not taken steps as extensive when it comes to online behavior, seldomly pursuing cases against internet tomfoolery [10]. In the US, the policing of online behavior falls on private companies, as they engage in censorship and content moderation to various levels. Therefore, with the merger of digital and real underway, if the authorities can’t engage in the pursuit of unwanted behavior online then we may be able to expect increases in their ability to moderate. My vision of what moderation looks like in the metaverse is the image of both moderators walking around the metaverse environments on patrol like many regular police officers do. However, at its worst, I see companies with metaverse platforms obtaining real life police units with the capability of jurisdiction over certain breaks of law or unwanted behavior. A haunting image in head of MPPD, or Meta Platforms Police Department that is able to not only punish people in the virtual world, but would get jurisdiction on certain crimes committed in the metaverse that the government would not want to handle. Think of it much like a blackwater but for the virtual space.

 


The truth of the matter is that I don’t really know if it’ll go as bad as I predict, but we never truly know what people are willing to do in the event that human behavior needs to be “controlled.”

References

[1]       Woman recalls “gang rape” in metaverse; concerns grow over making VR platforms safe from sexual predators [Internet]. cnbctv18.com. 2022 [cited 2022 Mar 19]. Available from: https://www.cnbctv18.com/technology/woman-recalls-gang-rape-in-metaverse-concerns-grow-over-making-vr-platforms-safe-from-sexual-predators-12396992.htm.

[2]       Archive VA, feed G author R. Meta adds ‘Personal Boundary’ to metaverse after ‘virtual gang rape’ [Internet]. New York Post. 2022 [cited 2022 Mar 19]. Available from: https://nypost.com/2022/02/04/meta-adds-personal-boundary-to-metaverse-after-virtual-gang-rape/.

[3]       Reality or Fiction?. Sexual Harassment in VR, The Proteus… | by Nina Jane Patel | Kabuni | Medium [Internet]. [cited 2022 Mar 19]. Available from: https://medium.com/kabuni/fiction-vs-non-fiction-98aa0098f3b0.

[4]       Chen C-P. Forming digital self and parasocial relationships on YouTube. Journal of Consumer Culture. 2016;16:232–254.

[5]       Yee N, Bailenson JN, Ducheneaut N. The Proteus Effect: Implications of Transformed Digital Self-Representation on Online and Offline Behavior. Communication Research. 2009;36:285–312.

[6]       Aaron Swartz [Internet]. [cited 2022 Mar 20]. Available from: https://fija.org/library-and-resources/library/law-and-legal-cases/aaron-swartz.html.

[7]       United States of America v. Ross William Ulbicht [Internet]. Findlaw. [cited 2022 Mar 20]. Available from: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-2nd-circuit/1862572.html.

[8]       Bowcott O, correspondent OBL affairs. UK lawyers uneasy about plan to prosecute hate speech at home. The Guardian [Internet]. 2020 Nov 4 [cited 2022 Mar 20]; Available from: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2020/nov/04/uk-lawyers-uneasy-about-plan-to-prosecute-hate-speech-at-home.

[9]       Online hate speech [Internet]. eSafety Commissioner. [cited 2022 Mar 20]. Available from: https://www.esafety.gov.au/research/online-hate-speech.

[10]     News ABC. Student’s arrest for racist post sparks free speech debate [Internet]. ABC News. [cited 2022 Mar 20]. Available from: https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/students-arrest-racist-post-sparks-free-speech-debate-77776153.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mandates and the Madness of Middle Managers

  Premise It’s been almost two years since COVID19 pandemic containment and quarantine protocols began in the United States. Since the protocols such as masking and travel restrictions began, I’ve had the luxury of traveling and living between two areas of the country that have had completely different attitudes levels of strictness from the very beginning. The first is a suburb of a large metropolitan area on the east coast (Metroburb), and the second is a medium sized town approximately 60 miles away from the metropolitan suburb (Medtown). As I’ve been about my business in both of these two areas without a mask for a very long time, only in Metroburb have I been actively harassed for not having a mask. To recount my experiences in Metroburb over the past 6 months: 2 x kicked out of a store for not having a mask 2 x followed by employees urging me to put a mask on 2 x cashiers refusing to accept my payments without a mask 1 x employees debate me on mask wearing 1 x people taking p...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Different Framework for Determining Human Rights

 Originally Written: 05/31/2019 Premise I had a conversation with a couple of my co-workers about a week before the time of this writing on the topic of child support. Although it revolved around whether or not child support should even exist in the first place, I found myself to be really uninformed on the topic. What proceeded after that discussion was a quick google search that led me to this quote from the Wikipedia page on child support: “The 1992 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child is a binding convention signed by every member nation of the United Nations and formally ratified by all but the United States. It declares that the upbringing and development of children and a standard of living adequate for the children's development is a common responsibility of both parents and a fundamental human right for children, and asserts that the primary responsibility to provide such for the children rests with their parents.” I found this interesting as the de...
Post a Comment
Read more

COVID19: Tales from the Field

  Premise Throughout the pandemic, there have been a small collection of strange cases or phenomenon that I have been taking notes on, but do not really exist in the literature. Some with an academic or questioning personality may approach such a blog post with a lot of skepticism. To try and alleviate this, I’ll provide some details about myself that should help with the legitimacy of my hearsay. I’m a mid-career scientist at a large research organization on the Eastern half of the United States. I previously worked in neuroscience, but I now work on clinical trials related to HIV and COVID19. We currently work on four clinical trials on COVID19, and two of them involve us reaching out to local hospitals in our region for current cases of COVID19. Our other two studies involve people who have recently recovered from COVID19 as we follow them over time. In other words, just trust me, bru. Tale 1: COVID-19 Vaccines and Surgery One of the nurses that I work ...
Post a Comment
Read more